Hm

May. 28th, 2009 11:32 pm
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (nick bw)
First: I still have a couple Dreamwidth invite codes, FYI

Second: So I was really excited when I first heard about Glee, because it looked like basically High School Musical but all the time and more show-tunesy. Also it took me like three seconds to develop a crush on the lead actress <3

Having watched the pilot...I kinda wish I hadn't. Because there are so many problems in just the 43 minutes I watched even the super-awesome right-up-my-alley choir-ized "Rehab" and "Don't Stop Believin'" aren't enough.

The two main glee club kids are, of course, straight and white, but the rest of the club is populated with tokens. There's cardboard stereotype sassy black girl, cardboard stereotype effeminate fashion-obsessed boy (who's probably meant to be gay), boy in a wheelchair whose only two jobs in the pilot are to a) be mediocre so the straight white male lead can replace him and b) serve as a prop to prove how Righteous and Noble the same guy is, and the Asian girl who has no concept of inappropriate behavior and apparently has no talent ("Do you have any talents?" [beat] [beat] "...we'll find you something") (I was going to say "talent beyond singing" since, ostensibly, all the glee kids can sing, but her audition was meant to be laughable, not good, and I got the impression she made it because of the lack of interest).

Female lead has gay fathers, and all we know about them is they pushed her hard into singing and dancing (I'm not sure if we're *meant* to get the impression they're aggressive "pageant dads" of the "Toddlers & Tiaras" ilk, but it's the impression I *got*); the Indian principal is a money-hungry Plot Device, the lead teacher's wife is a materialistic nag.

It left me with a seriously bad taste in my mouth. I love my show tunes (especially show-tuney pop/rock songs <3), I'd marry Jane Lynch in an instant, and I totally have a ladyboner for the lead glee girl's voice (and her ridiculous character, idk)...but I shouldn't be sitting here trying to figure out how a show can combine all those things and still leave me wondering if I wanna give it another chance.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (omg)
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/30089125/

I can't stop OMGing. CAN'T STOP. omg.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (wtf)
Fuck you, Governor Douglas.

I was trying not to get my hopes up too much. But we were so close. And in VT a bill can become law without the governor's signature - he could disapprove without actively veto-ing.

So FUCK YOU. Argh.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (nick bw)
This trainwreck, specifically the part starting here, left me wanting to organize my thoughts on reclamation a bit more.

I think of myself as a dyke. Generally, outside my own head, when I use "dyke" I'm talking about things I do which fit into stereotypes about non-porno lesbians - shaving my head was dykey, sports bra + ribbed tank + scuzzy jeans is a dykey outfit, etc. - but I identify as "dyke" more than "lesbian". Or, not necessarily more, but in a different way - when I'm just talking about my sexuality in a more straightforward, matter-of-fact way, I use "lesbian", but when I'm talking about it as a source of pride, as a challenged way of being that I don't feel any shame for and don't believe I should, I'm a big ol' dyke.

It's not an accident the derogatory term is the one I use when I'm talking about pride, about shame, about lesbianism as politically and morally charged. It's me very actively saying "not only will I not hate myself for the thing you hate me for, I will be proud of it".

Reclamation is taking a slur and turning it into a positive identifier, taking the power out of the hands of the bigots who spew hate speech and claiming it for one's own. It's taking someone's weapon and knocking it out of his hand. If someone wants to make me feel hated, scummy, worthless, it's telling him he has to find another goddamn way because calling me a dyke just doesn't do that anymore.

It does the opposite.

*

What happens all too often with reclamation is a backlash from Well-Meaning [insert privileged group] People, who are so sensitive and open-minded that the use of a slur offends them regardless of context. So, of course, because it makes the Well-Meaning Privileged uncomfortable, it just shouldn't be used at all. The intentions of the Well-Meaning Privileged are good, I don't use "Well-Meaning" sarcastically, but you know what they say about good intentions.

When you, Well-Meaning Straight Person, tell me I cannot call myself a dyke, you're disarming me, taking one of the few defense tactics I have and asking me to set it aside, leave myself open, in deference to your misplaced discomfort. Because I am far more likely to defer to Well-Meaning Discomfort than the bigot is, and when I set my weapon down he will be right there to pick it back up. And when he uses it, you will be uncomfortable.

Your discomfort is that of someone standing too close to a gun when it goes off, it's temporary deafness and ringing ears. You're not the one with the bullet wound.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (nick bw)
I thought this conversation would leave me angrier than it has; it's frustrating, but not on the level I was expecting. If nothing else, the fact that I went in to the conversation expecting to gain nothing and get nowhere leaves me rather immune to disappointment.

It's given me a chance to articulate things I believe but rarely talk about, at any rate.

I have started a post about what people are actually saying when they attempt neutrality by claiming there has been "bad behavior on both sides", while refusing to say anything about what that behavior is. I keep scrapping it; words aren't working for me the way I want them to lately.

Consider putting something up for auction, or bidding on something already up, at [livejournal.com profile] con_or_bust; being too broke to bid on a thing but wanting to contribute, I plan on auctioning fic off once I work out some specifics. If I decide it wouldn't be too much for the anxiety, which has been horrid lately, at least.

Also, if you're into poppy-cheesy-emo a la Fall Out Boy ([livejournal.com profile] mayqueen517 I'm looking at you, among others), check out The White Tie Affair and Secondhand Serenade. Cheesy, but very fun.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (drink up)
[I didn't provide the larger context of the massive racefail happening right now in my last post because it was so much about that individual fail, but I feel that a) it's an important conversation and b) it's easy to get lost in the massive sea of links out there and decide the signal-to-noise ratio is too unfavorable for you. Much thanks to [livejournal.com profile] wistfuljane for providing so much summary in handy easy-to-copy form]

What is RaceFail '09? [livejournal.com profile] daedala provided the shortest summary of RaceFail '09 here and it is as followed:
1. Bear writes a post about how to write the Other
2. Avalon's Willow critiques one of her books on racial tropes
3. Bear agrees unequivocally in writing
4. Commenters defend Bear in increasingly racist language.
5. Massive fail all over the internets.
6. Bear says that she was lying in 3. in order to model appropriate conversation.
But [livejournal.com profile] daedala's summary barely scratches the surface. Here are other more detailed, but still brief summaries of events: )

Racism 101 Resources )
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (bitch please)
There was a post at Feministing, titled Marge's Lesbian Fantasies, about Sunday night's episode of The Simpsons.

Or, rather, about a screenshot from the episode, because if the poster had actually seen it, she would've known that it wasn't Marge's lesbian fantasy, it was Homer's.

*sigh*

One more instance of a straight man fetishizing lesbian sex is totally something a feminst blog should be celebrating. I wish I could be so cheerful in the face of yet another reminder my sexuality is only okay when it benefits anyone but me.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (graar)
I rarely comment on the feminist blogs I read; it's some side effect of the social anxiety thing, that when I'm in an arena where I worry other people know more than me and will thus be able to see ignorance I didn't know existed in my words, I get antsy and just shut up. Although, honestly, if more people did that on their initial forays into activist theory, the world would be a lot awesomer.

Aaaaand I'm rambling already. Anyway I was reading Feministe earlier, and the story that's been circulating for a few days about a teacher who bound two black female students to teach her class about slavery finally showed up there. Reading the comments, I came across one that touched on an issue that's been on my mind lately. Thus:

I am not insensitive to the girl’s feelings, but as a parent of a young girl, I hope I am teaching her to be emotionally strong and to learn to deal with the situations she may one day face, including potentially traumatizing ones.


I was just talking with a friend about how troubling it is that the norm seems to be one should feel bad merely for being offended, that simply for being wronged, you are in fact wrong. Being hurt by something hurtful is not a sign of weakness, nor is it a character flaw, and I only hope I can teach the children I have any influence over that there is nothing wrong with speaking up when you are harmed - in any way.

As a society, we’d probably move a lot farther a lot faster if it wasn’t considered desirable to ignore wrongdoing in the name of “strength”.


I struggle - and it is a struggle, for me, because a large part of my anxiety stems from not wanting to be seen as an inconvenience - daily with this concept, that when someone wrongs me if I speak up I am doing something wrong. Somehow, the people whose biggest problem in the privilege system is being criticized for stomping on anything that will prevent them benefiting at other people's expense have convinced everyone else that criticizing is a more heinous offense than the stomping. You don't have to look any farther than the contempt surrounding "PC" - all political correctness is, really, is not using phraseology you know to be offensive.

And yet the mainstream response to "x term is offensive" is more likely to be "OH GOD HERE COME THE PC POLICE" than "gee, sorry I offended you."

There is nothing bad, or wrong, or shameful, or weak, about taking offense, and yet it's become codified in our culture that being offended is a crime in and of itself. And I, for one, am going to struggle, and examine, and push like Hell against my internalization of that idea until the day comes I don't feel like standing up and saying "your sexist bullshit is offensive" is likely to have more repercussions than the sexist bullshit.

You?
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (bitch please)
I understand the power of words, and more than that I understand the power differential. I know "asshole" doesn't hit the same as "cunt", that "wuss" doesn't sting like "pussy". I know when I'm feeling road ragey it's ten times more satisfying to think of the idiot going 10 in a 35 as "sweetheart" or "grandma" than anything else. I know how often it feels like the only word that fits has been made off-limits by those damn PC Police in my head, how frustrating that is, and how much that leaves me wondering how much one person's internal dialogue, how much one use of "slut" really matters. I know that even as high-and-mighty as I can get about this kind of thing, there are plenty of times I think the better option would be for everyone else to develop a thicker skin rather than for me to modify my habits.

I also know that I am better than that. I know I'm not the kind of person who is so self-centered as to privilege my inconvenience - which gets less and less inconvenient as time goes on - over the very real marginalization of entire groups of people. I know that I am capable of the thought required to understand the principles behind modifying my language, and that I am a good enough person to change my behavior in line with those principles.

I know I can't make anyone change their behavior. I know it's up to any given person what she says, what she thinks, what she does. I know if someone feels strongly enough, all the education, all the intelligence, all the pushing for much-needed social change in the world can't make him do a thing. And in the same way, no one can make me change things I feel strongly about. And I am smart enough to know discussion, disagreement, and any other manifestation of an individual's ideals aren't the same thing as force.

I know how misogynist, racist, homophobic, etc. language reflects on even people I know for a fact to be not misogynist, racist, homophobic, etc. I know "PC" is a buzzword used by assholes so when they complain they won't sound like the sort of person who complains about being asked to respect their fellow human beings - despite the fact that is what they're complaining about. And I know, above all, that I will never allow myself to look like one of those people.

Privilege

Sep. 30th, 2008 11:30 am
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (bitch please)
So...I was cleaning out my Documents folder this morning, and I found the beginnings of this long-winded blather about privilege and intersectionality...and I was gonna finish it up, but I realized it boiled down to just a couple sentences.

There is no finite number of privilege/oppression systems that can exist at any one tume; therefore, the existence of one oppression/privilege system doesn't negate the existence of others. Lack of one set of privileges doesn't mean you can't benefit from another (I see this a lot in discussions of white privilege: "I can't have white privilege, I'm poor!" No, what you don't have is class privilege - you still have white privilege [and depending on the person: straight, male, etc. privileges]). The fact that one oppression/privilege system may be more extreme/harsh/whatever than another doesn't mean the latter doesn't exist.

Any questions?

And from now on, rather than dignifying any "you can't have problems because other people do" comments with original responses, I'm just gonna link to this post. Because I do not have the energy.
hector_rashbaum: nicole anderson, b&w, big hair (FoB - Gimme Head)
So I haven't posted for a while. Mainly because...I'm pretty boring.

Things at home are the same as ever. Except different, slightly. Family are just as frustrating, in all the same ways, but they're trying. Well. Parents are, to an extent. Sister isn't, but she seems to be mellowing/maturing in general. Brother and I don't really bother with each other enough to frustrate. So. Yeah.

I've started taking Zoloft, or whatever the generic version is. A tiny amount, to make sure it doesn't omgpoison me, and even when they find the right dose it'll be 6-8 weeks before it works, but...it's a start. And I had my first appointment with a counselor Wednesday, and I'm going back next Thursday. So I'm, y'know, gonna get better.

(*sigh* I hooked up my old keyboard for when I'm at my desk, 'cause I've yet to find a way to set up the laptop that's comfy for both typing and reading, but I forgot it has a wonky spacebar, so it's a giant pain in the ass for exactly the sort of lengthy typing I wanted it for)

My car got fixed! Just needed his battery replaced (yes it's a he. It's a Donny. Mom's car is Ozzy. Dad's car is Marie; Ben's is Sharon. Except our neighbor/wife of our mechanic is Sharon [we actually refer to the garage as Sharon, ie "call Sharon, we need a tow truck" instead of "call J&L"] so it's probably a good thing I never need to refer to my brother's car), and he's good as...nowhere near new, but as new as I've ever seen him. He got to be the family car for a while! My mom's car died. Donny is a sucky family car. Two doors...we only had four people in him once, but that was plenty. I'm shorter than my sister so I had to sit behind my dad, and my knees were actually poking out in front of his back rest. We were all exceedingly happy to get Ozzy back.

I have a new bed. New ish. It was my aunt's bed in her apartment. It was weird at first; weirder because it's a full bed and since we've never had a full the only sheets we have for it were hers. And the only clean ones we had had been washed at her house, so they smell like her sheets. It's still a little weird, but less so every day. It's actually, however, gotten weirder not to have her around - since she lived so far away for so long, it wasn't weird to go for a while without seeing her...but since Mom has summers off (yay teaching) we saw a ton of her in the summer after she moved back up here, so it being summer we keep doing all these things we did with her...except without her now. We have our share of the ashes now, so we've all got to decide what we're each gonna do...I've picked out a necklace, so yeah.

My Sims is broken :( I've been whining at anyone who will listen. Hopefully the torrent for replacement Sims will hurry up so I don't have to wait too long for mindless timewasting.

I've been having trouble reconciling feminism with entertainment, lately. It's an odd sort of issue I'm having - in essence, the slightest issue with racism, sexism, heterosexism, etc. sets me right the fuck off. And, y'know, nothing is free of that shit. I imagine it will be one of those things I learn to deal with, like rice - my dad alternates between forgetting and refusing to believe I hate rice in any form, so he's always making nice dinners with unavoidable rice. Sometimes the otherstuff is worth eating around the rice, sometimes it isn't. So...racism is like rice. Or...yeah.

There is wank. I will make every effort I can to ensure the only person who has any right to question my friendship knows she has no reason to, and any public criticism of behavior or attitudes will be at best preceded by private discussion and at worst linked with the understanding private discussion is welcome. Anyone else can go to Hell.

In closing, [livejournal.com profile] laura_holt_pi is a twat. That is all.